“Because when you read a book as a child, it becomes part of your identity in a way that no other reading in your whole life does,” said Kathleen Kelly to Joe Fox, her business competitor turned online friend turned beau in the 1998 romantic comedy movie, You’ve Got Mail. Starring Meg Ryan as Kathleen and Tom Hanks as Joe, You’ve Got Mail (Figure 1) caught my attention for its blend of friendship and humor around the children’s books business competition in New York City (“NYC”).

You’ve Got Mail – movie poster
Note. Taken from https://www.themoviedb.org/movie/9489-you-ve-got-mail/images/posters
Kathleen, who has an astronomical knowledge of children’s books, finally had to close her ‘small independent’ bookstore, The Shop Around the Corner (Figure 2), which she inherited from her mother, after 42 years of serving the community.

The Shop Around the Corner
Note. Taken from Fleming, 2018.
The reason, as you might guess, was losing a competition to a giant bookstore chain, Fox & Sons Books (Figure 3), which Joe’s family owned.

Fox & Sons Books
Note. Taken from Best, 2014.
Unlike Kathleen’s little bookstore that employed people with a knowledge of children’s books and where the storytelling was part of the regular program (Figure 4), Joe’s gigantic bookstore offers a book café to attract more customers coming in and create an alternate for cashing in their dollars (Figure 5), and probably compensate for the lack of product knowledge their staff has, much like those who work in shoe stores: they could only read the labels and price tags (Fialkoff, 1999).

Storytelling hour at The Shop Around the Corner
Note. Taken from https://www.imdb.com/

A book café inside Fox & Sons Books
Note. Taken from https://www.onthesetofnewyork.com/youvegotmail.html
You’ve Got Mail was one of a re-spin of a 1940 romantic comedy, titled The Shop Around the Corner, starring Margaret Sullavan and James Stewart (Figure 6).

The Shop Around the Corner – movie poster
Note. Taken from https://www.imdb.com/
Beyond its $250 million worldwide box office, many acknowledged the impact You’ve Got Mail had on American culture, including changes in the bookstore landscape in the coming years, the rise of online dating and internet catfishing, and the popularity of Starbucks (Clark, 2018; Tsintziras, 2021).
Barnes & Noble: The real-life Fox & Sons Books
Though founded in 1873, the first Barnes & Noble (B&N) flagship store opened in NYC in 1917 by William Barnes and G. Cliford Noble (Barnes & Noble, n.d.).

B&N flagship store in NYC
Note. Taken from https://www.tripadvisor.com/
After many years of losses, B&N was finally acquired in 2019 by Elliott Management, a private equity firm, under the leadership of James Daunt (Milliot, 2025). While big publishers were happy about this news, Daunt’s policy to narrow B&N’s collection by cutting the ‘boring and tedious’ books has hurt indie publishers as well as the indie bookstores. Many were reported to be closing due to the opening of B&N’s new stores in their area (Wright, 2025). To give you some ideas of what a B&N store looks like, especially from the inside, let me share some pictures I took during one of my visits to the bookstore (Figure 8).

B&N store in Nebraska
Note. Photograph taken by the Author, 2026.
To bring us to a close, allow me to share with you one of my favorite quotes from the movie, which was mentioned by Joe to Kathleen in one of his emails: “The whole purpose of places like Starbucks is for people with no decision-making ability whatsoever to make six decisions just to buy one cup of coffee. Short, tall, light, dark, caf, decaf, low-fat, non-fat, etc. So, people who don’t know what the hell they’re doing or who on earth they are can, for only $2.95, get not just a cup of coffee but an absolutely defining sense of self: Tall. Decaf. Cappuccino.”
What is your opinion on the business competition between the indie bookstores and the giant bookstores? As librarians, which store will you partner with?
References
Barnes & Noble. (n.d.). History. https://www.barnesandnobleinc.com/about-bn/history/
Best, J.D. (2014, Dec 2). Fox & Sons Books—Revenge at last.
https://jamesdbest.blogspot.com/2014/12/fox-sons-booksrevenge-at-last.html
Clark, C. (2018, Dec 17). You’ve got mail, 20 years later. Alternate Ending. https://www.alternateending.com/blog/youve-got-mail-whats-held-up
Fialkoff, F. (1999). Mimicking the Library. Library Journal, 124(3), 136.
Fleming, K. (2018, Dec 14). How ‘You’ve Got Mail’ made NYC a rom-com star. New York Post. https://nypost.com/2018/12/14/how-youve-got-mail-made-nyc-a-rom-com-star/
Milliot, J. (2025, Jun 26). Independent publishers are fed up with Barnes & Noble. Publishers Weekly. https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry
news/bookselling/article/98035-independent-publishers-are-fed-up-with-barnes-noble-s buying-practices.html
Tsintziras, A. (2021, Sep 9). You’ve got mail: 10 things that have aged well about the movie. Screen Rant. https://screenrant.com/youve-got-mail-movie-aged-well/
Wright, A. (2025, Dec 22). Barnes & Noble CEO’s defiant rebuttal against mom and pop bookstore that blames their closure on his chain sparking real-life You’ve Got Mail battle. Daily Mail. https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15346231/bookcafe-barnes-noble battle-chicago-youve-got-mail.html
KUBIK Oktober 2021: “School library programs then and now, a sharing session”
KUBIK Oktober: School Library Programs Then and Now: a Sharing Session Pada hari Sabtu, 23 Oktober 2…
Pentingnya Story Telling untuk Memupuk Keterampilan Literasi Anak
(Tangerang Selatan, 29/01/2021) Asosiasi Pekerja Profesional Informasi Sekolah Indonesia ( APISI ) k…
Presiden APISI Hanna Chaterina George, S.S.,M.I.Kom. Menjadi Narasumber Pada Webinar dan Workshop Perspustakaan Sekolah Universitas Surabaya
Surabaya (18-11-2020), Presiden Asosiasi Pekerja Profesional Informasi Sekolah Indonesia ( APISI ) H…
Presiden APISI menjadi Narasumber Pelatihan Tenaga Perpustakaan yang diselenggarakan oleh MKS SMTA MPK KEUSKUPAN AGUNG JAKARTA
Jakarta, (12-11-2020) Presiden Asosiasi Pekerja Profesional Informasi Sekolah Indonesia ( APISI ) Ha…
Kunjungan APISI ke perpustakaan SMP 22 Muhammadiyah Setiabudi Pamulang
Tangerang Selatan, (6/11/2020) Asosiasi Pekerja Profesional Informasi Sekolah Indonesia ( APISI ) me…
You’ve Got Mail: A Romantic Comedy Movie that Changed the Bookstore Game in America
“Because when you read a book as a child, it becomes part of your identity in a way that no other r…
Dari Perpustakaan Menuju Duta Guru CBP Rupiah DIY 2026
“Setiap perjalanan selalu dimulai dari keberanian untuk mencoba. Menang atau kalah hanyalah bagian d…
Rory Gilmore: A Fictional Character Turns a Reading Model for Young Female Readers
“I want to read like Rory Gilmore, because I am obsessed with her,” said one American Book Tuber. “…
Menggaungkan Semangat ‘Librarian Leader’ yang Proaktif dan Berdampak
Merayakan perjalanan dua dekade di dunia literasi, Asosiasi Pekerja Profesional Informasi Sekolah In…
From Horton to the Grinch: A Story of Dr. Seuss
If you are familiar with Horton (Figure 1), the elephant, then you might as well be familiar with so…
The TPA Score and Indonesia’s Readiness for Its 2045 Vision
he first time I read the roadmap to Golden Indonesia 2045 (Kementerian, 2019), a question popped int…



